top of page

A Wasted Life

  • Writer: sarahstiltner
    sarahstiltner
  • Dec 28, 2025
  • 3 min read

Updated: 3 days ago

and the sacred pressure to make it matter



I think one of the hardest truths I have had to face since leaving a high-control group is this: a significant portion of my life feels wasted.


Not misunderstood. Not misused. Wasted.


Time, energy, devotion, care, all poured into something that harmed people I loved, that demanded suffering and then called it faithfulness, that took and took and returned explanations instead of repair. There were people hurt there. Profoundly. And I was part of that system.


Leaving does not erase that, rather it has sharpened it.


Once you see the harm clearly, the weight of what was lost becomes almost unbearable. Not just your own years, but the cumulative damage—the marriages strained, the children shaped by fear, the bodies exhausted, the minds narrowed, the grief made unspeakable. When I look back, I feel the crushing weight of waste.


And so there has been a sacred pressure to make it matter.


If all of that suffering simply disappears into nothing–if it was endured for no reason, if it produced no freedom, no truth, no growth— then something inside me cannot bear it. I cannot tolerate the idea that so much pain was demanded and then meant nothing at all.


So now I insist that the cost of leaving matters.

The difficulty matters.The loss matters.The pain matters.


Not because suffering is virtuous, but because it must count for something different than what the system claimed. Leaving was not just a choice. It was a price. And if freedom, health, and growth do not require a real cost, then what was taken from us was never necessary in the first place.


That is what I cannot accept.


This is why I am so resistant to language that resolves too quickly. Why I recoil from stories that turn harm into character development or endurance into proof of goodness. I lived inside that logic for too long. I watched it break people. I watched it keep them quiet.


I will not let that happen again. Not in my life, and not in my words.


This is also why leaving is so painful. Because walking away does not just mean starting over. It means carrying the full awareness of what should never have been required, and refusing to let it be dismissed as a lesson learned or a phase outgrown. It means holding the grief without redeeming it falsely.


There is a terrible temptation here: to believe that I must now extract meaning in order to justify the years that were taken. To believe that if I cannot turn loss into growth, then the waste wins.


But I am learning something slower and harder.

The work is not to redeem the suffering.The work is to refuse to waste it again.


Freedom has a cost. Health has a cost. Growth has a cost. Leaving required something real from me, and I will not pretend otherwise. That cost does not make the harm acceptable. But it does mean that what was endured is now being spent toward something true.


Some lives contain damage that should never have happened. Some systems leave wreckage behind them. Naming that does not make us bitter. It makes us honest.


I cannot undo the waste. But I can insist that the price of leaving was necessary, not because the suffering was good, but because freedom is.


That is the line I will not cross again.

1 Comment


John Bunyan
John Bunyan
Jan 28

As someone who also grew up in -- and also left at a significant cost -- the same high-control religious group that you were in, Sarah, your words resonate deeply. I've long felt that a significant portion of my years -- no, decades -- on this Earth were wasted (stolen, really) by a group that viewed them as only valuable for its own self-perpetuation and enrichment. And now, I do my best to find ways to make the remaining decades I have *count*.

Like
© 2035 by Andy Decker. Powered and secured by Wix
bottom of page